If you haven’t heard yet, Dr. Destler didn’t dye his hair orange at the halftime
of the men’s basketball game last Sunday. He didn’t even dye half. Not enough
people showed up to the game. While some blame televised post-season football
games as the reason for such low turnout (see “SG Update”), I’m not entirely convinced that this is was what was going on the afternoon of January 11.
Personally, I think RIT students are tired of the gimmicks. The thought of a temporarily
carrot-topped university president is somewhat amusing, but is it enough of a motivating
factor to get people off of their couches and onto the gym bleachers? Apparently
not — not even for a few hours. Never mind a consistent fanbase over the course of a
season. Likewise, the women’s sport event punch cards are a cute idea, but I’m just
not sure how often you can drag people out of their dorms with the promise of gift
baskets. Raffles are exciting, but so is sleep. These attempts at improving campus life
and raising school spirit are admirable, but the methods are somewhat misguided.
For example: As I write this, 21 administrators are participating in Student
Government’s Dorm Challenge. It’s a fascinating stunt, and I’m sure a lot of
interesting stories will come out of it — we’ll be covering them on our website. But
several months down the line, how meaningful will any of this be? Is this going
to have any long term impact on the way housing is handled? I’m skeptical.
Similarly, even if Dr. Destler did dye his hair, would the attendance at the
basketball games remain high for the rest of the season? If every student at RIT
went to two or three Spirit Week events, would any of that happiness with RIT
carry over into the following month? If every student wore orange and brown
next Friday, would school spirit be improved for even the following week?
The problem with gimmicks is that once the novelty wears off, you’re not left with
anything of substance underneath. Gimmicks can get people excited for a short while,
but the effects are not long lasting. (And no, the answer to this is not to run a long
string of gimmicks one after another. Student Government, I’m looking at you.)
Shoving scads of gimmicks down students’ throats doesn’t make the original dish
any more appetizing; if anything, it just induces gag reflexes. Instead of brainstorming
more gimmicks for the remainder of this quarter, perhaps our student leaders ought to
devote that energy to projects of longer lasting worth. For now, I’m all gimmicked out.
Laura Mandanas
Editor in Chief
Comments
Comments solely the opinion of the readers who post them.
Comments FAQ
|
| |
|
Fri, Jan 23 2009 @ 6:47 am |
Talking about gimmick . . . before reading this
here review . . . I had dyed my hair carrot top red. I wanted to me in high spirit while reading this fine editorial piece.
On a serious note . . . I thought this Laura's
editorial had made some very good points. However, I disagree with her on calling the 21 administrators participating in the Student
Government's Dorm Challenge a gimmick. I think
the challenge is sincere and it appears that they
are trying to meet the students half way.
The bottom line . . . sometime the students have to quit complaining and show some appreciation.
In America . . . parents, mentors and teachers and school administrators try their best to come up with better way to aid the students to having a good education. In other countries, they not trying to kiss up to the students to get a great
education. Nah! In other countries . . . there
not such thing as spoiling their students. Either
you perform on top level or you don't exist.
In other countries . . . its an honor to be a students . . . foreign students don't need the
perks that American students has and need.
C'mon . . RIT . . . don't be sooooo spoil . . .
meet your elder half way! When you blink your
eyes . . . and time passes . . . then one day,
you will find yourself in the same position. The tasks of trying to motivate your own kids or some one you are trying to mentor. Think about it!
--Benjamin Williams/BW Comix
|
|
Benjamin Williams |
| |
|
Sat, Jan 24 2009 @ 10:35 am |
I agree with a lot of the points made in Laura's editorial and I had really hoped that the Dorm Challenge would have been treated more like a social experiment than just a way to increase school spirit.
To their credit, all of the administrators who participated in this did an excellent job and should be commended for their participation. I just feel as though the Dorm Challenge wasn't designed to have them really experience dorm living. Sure, 5am fire alarms are annoying, but two nights in a dorm is a piece of cake.
I say next year have them in the dorms for a few weeks. They can still go to their jobs, but have them go to evening classes as well. After all, a lot of students do have jobs outside of classes. Have them take tests and be graded, have them write term papers. Give them the real academic experience. Then give them the real dorm experience, something more real than three days.
Make them like a real student and put them in with an individual who didn't sign up to have them as a roommate. This person may have nothing in common with them, but they're stuck together. Have them do their laundry on a weeknight (though you should warn the women that their laundry may be stolen if they're not watching it). Put them in an overcrowded room. Give them a meal plan so that they'll have to try to figure out how to eat at Gracies as little as possible.
Next year make it more Zimbardo and less novel. Only then can you honestly call it a dorm challenge. |
|
Michelle Comeau |
| |
|
Mon, Jan 26 2009 @ 12:59 am |
|
I agree with a lot of Laura's comments as well, but really, what can you do to boost school spirit and sports games attendance? I agree, these gimmicks are a little much sometimes and do nothing long term. Lets face it. We go to a tech school. We're not exactly renowned for our athletic ability, much less our interest in sports. I think the administration is at least trying to bolster school spirit. Any attempt is a good attempt. |
|
Dan Lovria |
| |
Add Your Own
|